Natalie's Millersport Delivery Menu - Amherst

Menu
Restaurant Info

Natalie's Millersport

Information

Natalie's Millersport

807 Millersport Hwy, Amherst, NY 14226

We Are Focused On Providing The Freshest Homemade Food With The Highest Levels Of Customer Satisfaction

Ordering Hours

SundayClosed

Monday10 AM - 5:30 PM

Tuesday10 AM - 5:30 PM

Wednesday10 AM - 5:30 PM

Thursday10 AM - 5:30 PM

Friday10 AM - 5:30 PM

Saturday11 AM - 2:30 PM

Chicken Lemon & Rice

$7.09

Creamy Cauliflower

$7.09

Chicken Barley

$7.09

Mixed Bean & Rice

$7.09

Hummus

Ground chick peas, garlic, lemon, and tahini (a vegan sesame seed paste) served with a pita

$9.49

Baba Ganoush

Roasted eggplant dip with garlic tahini and lemon, served with pita

$11.79

Spanakopita

(greek spinach pie ) layers of phyllo dough, stuffed with spinach, egg, feta cheese, and onions, baked to perfection

$11.79

Foul Maddammas

Cooked fava beans, mixed in a lemon -garlic olive oil dressing, served with a pita.

$11.79

Greek French Fries

Crispy fries covered with feta cheese and sides of Greek dressing and dill sauce

$11.79

Cajun Fries

French Fries tossed in Cajun Seasoning

$5.89

French Fries

$4.79

Falafel Fritters

$8.29

Cole Slaw

$4.79

Macaroni Salad

$4.79

Rice

Seasoned rice with onions and carrots

$4.79

Tzatziki

2 oz or 8 oz. of creamy cucumber sauce, served with pita

$1.79

Tabouli Salad

Freshly chopped parsley, tomatoes, onions, and cracked wheat in a lemon olive oil dressing

$9.49

Greek Salad

Freshly chopped lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and feta cheese, served with a side of our homemade Greek dressing

$14.19

Open Chicken Souvlaki

Marinated grilled chicken served with a Greek salad, a side of pita and our homemade Greek dressing on the side. Greek salad consists of romaine lettuce , tomatoes, onions, banana peppers , black olives and feta.

$20.09

Open Steak Souvlaki

Marinated grilled beef served with a Greek salad , a side of pita and our homemade Greek dressing on the side. Greek salad consists of romaine lettuce , tomatoes, onions, banana peppers , black olives and feta.

$21.29

Open Falafel Salad

Three falafel fritters served with a Greek salad, a side of pita, and our homemade Greek dressing. Greek salad consists of romaine lettuce , tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, black olives and feta.

$20.09

Chicken Souvlaki Pita Pocket

Marinated grilled chicken stuffed into a pita pocket with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and feta cheese. Served with a side of our homemade Greek dressing

$14.19

Chicken Shawarma Wrap

Marinated grilled chicken, wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, pickles, french fries and our homemade garlic-mayo spread

$14.19

Beef Shawarma Wrap

Marinated grilled sliced beef, wrapped in a flat pita with tomatoes, pickles, onions, and our homemade tahini sauce

$14.19

Chicken Gyro Wrap

Marinated grilled chicken wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, feta cheese, and our homemade dill sauce

$14.19

Beef Gyro Wrap

Marinated beef, wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, feta cheese, and our homemade dill sauce

$14.19

Chicken Kabob Wrap

Marinated grilled chicken, wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and our homemade garlic-mayo spread

$14.19

Kafta Wrap

Grilled seasoned ground beef, wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, ,pickles, and our homemade hummus spread

$14.19

Steak Kabob Wrap

Marinated grilled beef, wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and our homemade garlic-mayo spread

$14.19

Steak Souvlaki Pita Pocket

Marinated steak stuffed into a pita pocket with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and feta cheese. Served with a side of our homemade Greek dressing

$14.19

Gluten Free Wrap

Please specify what kind of wrap you want in the notes section (all wraps listed in wrap section) Disclaimer : We are not a dedicated gluten free kitchen, cross contamination may occur.

$16.59

Falafel Wrap

Ground chickpeas, spices, deep fried then wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, and our homemade tahini sauce

$14.19

Megaderra Wrap

Lentils and rice wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, served with a side of hot sauce.

$14.19

Spinach & Leek Wrap

Cooked spinach, leeks,cracked wheat wrapped in a flat pita with tomatoes, and feta cheese

$14.19

Hummus & Tabouli Wrap

Our homemade hummus spread and tabouli salad stuffed into a pita pocket or a flat pita wrap

$14.19

Cauliflower Wrap

Fried Cauliflower, fresh tomatoes, and our homemade tahini sauce wrapped in a flat pita

$14.19

Vegetarian Kibby Wrap

Potatoes, cracked wheat, spinach, onions, and garbanzo beans, baked and then wrapped in a flat pita with lettuce, tomatoes, feta cheese, and our homemade greek dressing

$12.99

Gluten Free Wrap

Please specify what kind of wrap you want in the notes section (all wraps listed in wrap section) Disclaimer : We are not a dedicated gluten free kitchen, cross contamination may occur.

$16.59

Falafel Wrap Combo

Our Famous crispy fried falafel fritters served in a pita wrap with lettuce, tomatoes pickles and our house made tangy Tahiti sauce.

$18.89

Chicken Kabob Wrap Combo

$18.89

Steak Kabob Wrap Combo

$20.09

Chicken Shawarma Wrap Combo

$18.89

Beef Shawarma Wrap Combo

$18.89

Megaderra Wrap Combo

$18.89

Spinach & Leek Wrap Combo

$18.89

Gyro Wrap Combo

$20.09

Open Gyro Wrap Combo

$20.09

Open Chicken Kabob Combo

$18.89

Chicken Finger

5 pieced of Tyson brand chicken, served with fries, blue cheese and hot sauce on the side

$17.69

Fish Fry

11 ounce beer battered Icelandic brand haddock, served with fries, coleslaw, buttered roll and a side of tartar sauce

$21.29

Cheese Burger

$17.69

Bacon Burger

$18.89

Turkey Club Sandwich

$18.89

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$18.89

Grilled Ham & Cheese Sandwich

$17.69

BLT Sub (whole)

Crispy bacon topped with fresh lettuce, Tomatoes and Mayo all on a toasted 8" hoagie roll

$14.19

BLT Sub (half)

Crispy bacon topped with fresh lettuce, Tomatoes and Mayo all on a toasted 8" hoagie roll

$9.49

Chicken Finger Sub (whole)

Crispy Tyson brand chicken fingers topped with your choice of hot, medium, or mild served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions blue cheese or Mayo

$17.69

Chicken Finger Sub (half)

Crispy Tyson brand chicken fingers topped with your choice of hot, medium, or mild served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions blue cheese or Mayo

$12.99

Chicken Ranch Sub (whole)

Grilled chicken tenderloin topped with sauteed onions melted mozzarella cheese fresh lettuce, tomatoes, ranch dressing and a drizzle of hot sauce

$17.69

Chicken Ranch Sub (half)

Grilled chicken tenderloin topped with sauteed onions melted mozzarella cheese fresh lettuce, tomatoes, ranch dressing and a drizzle of hot sauce

$12.99

Steak and Cheese Sub (whole)

Chopped up steak topped with sauteed onions melted mozzarella cheese fresh lettuce and tomatoes with a little Mayo

$17.69

Steak and Cheese Sub (half)

Chopped up steak topped with sauteed onions melted mozzarella cheese fresh lettuce and tomatoes with a little Mayo

$12.99

Turkey Sub (whole)

$14.19

Turkey Sub (half)

$9.49

Turkey w Bacon Sub (whole)

$16.59

Turkey w Bacon Sub (half)

$11.79

Cheeseburger Sub (whole)

$17.69

Cheeseburger Sub (half)

$12.99

Ham Sub (whole)

$14.19

Ham Sub (half)

$9.49

Side Pita

$2.39

Side Greek Dressing

$1.49

Side Garlic Sauce

$1.49

Side Dill Sauce

$1.49

Side Tahini

$1.49

Side Feta

$2.39

Chicken Skewer

$5.39

Beef Skewer

$5.39

Chicken Fingers 3 Piece

3 pc chicken fingers with French Fries

$14.19

Cheese Burger

Served with fries

$14.19

Grilled Cheese

Choose White or Rye. Served with French fries

$12.99

French Fries (Small)

$4.19

French Fries (Large)

$6.49

Bottled Water

$2.69

Pelligrino

$4.19

Coke

$4.19

Diet Coke

$4.19

Root Beer

$4.19

Ginger Ale

$4.19

Unsweetened Iced Tea

$4.19

Snapple Raspberry

$4.19

Snapple Peach

$4.19

Snapple Lemon

$4.19

Diet Snapple Raspberry

$4.19

Diet Snapple Peach

$4.19

Diet Snapple Lemon

$4.19

Lemonade

$3.59

Tabouli Small Tray

Freshly chopped parsley, tomatoes, onions, and cracked wheat in a lemon olive oil dressing

$54.29

Tabouli Large Tray

Freshly chopped parsley, tomatoes, onions, and cracked wheat in a lemon olive oil dressing

$101.49

Fattoush Small Tray

Freshly chopped lettuce, parsley, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and toasted pita, mixed in our homemade garlic -lemon olive oil dressing

$54.29

Fattoush Largel Tray

Freshly chopped lettuce, parsley, tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and toasted pita, mixed in our homemade garlic -lemon olive oil dressing

$101.49

Greek Small Tray

Freshly chopped romaine lettuce, tomatoes, banana peppers, onions, black olives and feta cheese, served with a side of our homemade Greek dressing.

$54.29

Greek Large Tray

Freshly chopped romaine lettuce, tomatoes, banana peppers, onions, black olives and feta cheese, served with a side of our homemade Greek dressing.

$101.49

Hummus Appetizer Small Tray

Ground chickpeas, garlic, lemon, and tahini (a vegan sesame seed paste) served with a pita.

$54.29

Hummus Appetizer Large Tray

Ground chickpeas, garlic, lemon, and tahini (a vegan sesame seed paste) served with a pita.

$101.49

Single Falafel 50 Count

$88.59

Single Falafel 100 Count

$177.09

Small Tray Dill Sauce

Serves about 25 people comes with pita

$47.29

Spanakopita Small tray

(greek spinach pie ) layers of phyllo dough, stuffed with spinach, egg, feta cheese, and onions, baked to perfection.

$77.89

Spanakopita Large Tray

(greek spinach pie ) layers of phyllo dough, stuffed with spinach, egg, feta cheese, and onions, baked to perfection.

$117.99

Rice Small Tray

White Rice, Seasoned and mixed with carrots and onions for extra flavor

$54.29

Rice Large Tray

White Rice, Seasoned and mixed with carrots and onions for extra flavor

$101.49

Baklava Small Tray

$70.79

Baklava Large Tray

$117.99

Rice Pudding Small Tray

$54.29

Rice Pudding Large Tray

$94.49

Large Greek Combo

Lrg Tray Greek Salad, 25 Skewers of Chicken or Beef, Sm tray of Rice, Qt. Tzatziki, Pita, Greek dressing on the side. Feeds 20-25 people

$353.99

Medium Greek Combo

Lg. tray of Greek salad, 15 skewers of Chicken or Beef, Sm. tray of Rice, Qt tzatziki, Pita , and Greek dressing. Feeds about 15 people

$278.49

Small Greek Combo

Sm. tray of Greek salad, 10 skewers of Chicken, or Beef, Sm. tray of Rice, 1/2 qt tzatziki, Pita , and Greek dressing. Feeds about 10 people

$195.89

Mediterranean Feast

Sm Tray Tabouli, Sm Tray Hummus, 2 Dozen Falafel, Sm Tray Baba Ghanoush, Sm Tray of Rice. Includes Pita

$283.19

Appetizer Platter

Dozen Falafel, Baba Ghanoush, Quart Tabouli, Quart Hummus

$101.49

Mixed Wrap Combo Platter

Choose any 10 of our Chicken, Beef, or Vegetarian Wraps and Small Tray of Hummus Appetizer

$195.89

Skewer of Chicken

One skewer of chicken

$7.09

Skewer of Steak

One skewer of steak

$7.09

We offer delivery and takeout for this restaurant.

Ordering Hours

SundayClosed

Monday10:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Tuesday10:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Wednesday10:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Thursday10:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Friday10:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Saturday11:00 AM - 2:30 PM

We Are Focused On Providing The Freshest Homemade Food With The Highest Levels Of Customer Satisfaction

You currently do not have any items. Please add items to your cart before checking out.

Natalie's Millersport

Natalie's Millersport

Homemade Soups

Starters

Salads

Wraps & Pitas

Vegetarian Wraps & Pitas

Mediterranean Combo Plates

Dinners

Hot & Grilled Sandwiches

Submarines

Desserts

Extras

Kids Menu

Drinks

Catering Salads

Catering Starters

Catering Desserts

Catering Combos & Platters

Ordering Hours